Management of Achilles Ruptures

The Achilles tendon is the largest tendon in the body, and a rupture usually happens suddenly during sport or a quick push-off, often with a feeling of being kicked in the back of the leg. I treat Achilles ruptures in London, at Guy’s and St Thomas’ and privately at The Wellington Hospital and 30 Devonshire Street. Ruptures can be treated with or without surgery, and I use the same accelerated rehabilitation programme for both.

I think I’ve ruptured my Achilles. What should I do?

Get assessed as soon as possible. Early treatment matters, whichever route you take. If the foot isn’t placed in the right position quickly, the tendon ends can drift apart, which affects both surgical and non-surgical results. I assess the tendon with ultrasound in clinic, which shows how far apart the ends are and helps decide the best treatment. Contact us for an urgent appointment.

Should I have surgery or treatment in a boot?

This is the main decision, and there is no single right answer. Large trials have shown that when both groups follow the same accelerated rehabilitation, function at one year is about the same with or without surgery. The real trade-offs are:

  • Re-rupture. Surgery lowers the chance of the tendon tearing again. In the largest recent trial, about 1 in 16 people re-ruptured without surgery, compared with about 1 in 170 after surgery. Other studies using a boot like the one I use report lower re-rupture rates without surgery, around 2 to 5 in 100. Almost all re-ruptures happen in the first six months.
  • Strength. Without surgery, the gap in the tendon fills with weaker healing tissue, so the tendon can heal slightly longer. This can mean less push-off power and a smaller calf. On average, people who have surgery have around 18% more calf strength at 18 months. This matters most for sprinting, jumping and sports with sudden changes of direction.
  • Return to work. On average, about three weeks sooner after surgery, which can matter if you do manual work or are self-employed.
  • Surgical complications. Surgery adds a small risk of wound problems and nerve irritation. Overall, complications affect about 5 in 100 people after surgery and about 2 in 100 without, mostly minor wound problems.

Surgery may suit you better if

  • You are young, very active or a competitive athlete
  • Avoiding a re-rupture is very important to you
  • You were seen late after the injury, or this is a re-rupture
  • The tendon has pulled off the heel bone
  • The tendon ends stay more than about 1 cm apart, even with the foot pointed down

Treatment in a boot may suit you better if

  • You have diabetes, poor circulation, or take steroids, as these increase wound problems
  • You smoke or are significantly overweight
  • You are older or less active
  • The rupture is partial, or the tendon ends come together well with the foot pointed down

Whichever you choose, the boot programme only works if you follow it strictly, so it is worth being honest with yourself about whether you can. Surgery does not remove the need for the boot, as the rehabilitation is the same.

What does surgery involve?

The two ends of the torn tendon are stitched together with strong sutures. In most cases I use a minimally invasive technique (PARS) through a small incision at the back of the heel, which has a lower risk of wound problems than traditional open surgery. For ruptures very close to the heel or high up in the calf, or where treatment has been delayed, an open repair through a longer incision is more reliable.

Treatment without surgery

Treatment without surgery became widely used in the UK after good results from a team in Swansea, using early weight-bearing in a special boot. You can read their original paper. This approach, known as SMART (Swansea Morriston Achilles Rupture Treatment), is the basis of the rehabilitation I use for all my patients, with or without surgery. A large UK trial (UKSTAR) found that early weight-bearing in a boot gives results as good as a plaster cast, without more re-ruptures.

The rehabilitation programme

The aim is to bring the tendon ends close together, by holding the foot pointing downwards at first, and then gradually bring the foot back to a normal angle as the tendon heals. Weight-bearing and calf exercises are increased step by step.

For the first two weeks you are in a plaster with the foot pointing down. You are then fitted with a VACOped boot, which has an adjustable hinge. The lower lock is moved down step by step, each step allowing another 10 degrees of movement. This is a general guide, and your programme may be adjusted.

Weeks Boot or cast Walking and exercise
0–2 Plaster with the foot pointing down No weight on the leg, crutches
2–5 VACOped position 3, locked at 30° Weight-bearing with crutches, wedged sole
5–7 Position 2, movement between 30° and 20° Full weight, wedged sole
7–8 Position 1, movement between 30° and 10° Full weight, flat sole, start resistance band exercises
8–9 Position 0, movement between 30° and 0° Full weight, flat sole, continue exercises
9–10 Fully unlocked Full weight, flat sole, continue exercises
10 Boot off Clinic visit

You can watch videos from the manufacturer to help you get used to the boot.

Clinic visits

Week 2: the VACOped boot is fitted and the programme explained.

Week 5: an important check as the boot starts to unlock. I assess the tendon, with ultrasound if needed, and arrange physiotherapy.

Week 10: usually the final visit. If all is going well, you continue with physiotherapy.

Returning to activity

Low-impact exercise, such as swimming and gentle running, can usually start from around 12 weeks. High-impact sports such as football, rugby and sprinting should wait until around six months, and be reintroduced with your physiotherapist. If there are any concerns, I may see you again before you return to sport.

Recovery takes time, whichever treatment you have. At one year, only about 4 in 10 people are back to their previous level of sport, and many continue to improve after that.

The risky weeks for re-rupture

Most re-ruptures happen in the first six months, often when coming out of the boot or after an unexpected strain, such as a slip or missing a step on the stairs. Take particular care during this time.

What are the risks?

These should be read alongside the general risks of foot and ankle surgery.

Risks of surgery

  • Wound problems and infection. The skin over the back of the heel has a poor blood supply, so wound healing is the main concern. Deep infection affects about 1 in 100 people. Mild cases settle with antibiotics, but severe cases can need further operations, sometimes with plastic surgery. The risk is much higher if you smoke, have diabetes or take medicines that weaken the immune system.
  • Nerve irritation. The sural nerve runs near the back of the ankle and supplies feeling to the outer side of the foot. Irritation can cause numbness or tingling there, in about 2 to 5 in 100 people after minimally invasive repair. It is usually temporary but can occasionally be permanent.
  • Scar problems. Occasionally the scar is thick or sticks to the tendon underneath.

Risks with or without surgery

  • Re-rupture or a stretched tendon. More common without surgery, as described above. A tendon that heals stretched can leave the calf weak when pushing off. If this causes problems, surgery may be needed, which can be more complex than a first repair.
  • Blood clots. An Achilles rupture is one of the highest-risk lower leg injuries for blood clots in the leg (deep vein thrombosis) or lungs (pulmonary embolism). About 1 in 25 to 1 in 30 people develop a clot in the first three months, most often in the first month, while the leg is in plaster and not taking weight. The risk is higher without surgery, if you are over 50, if you or a close relative have had a clot, and in women taking hormonal contraception. I use a recognised risk score to assess you, and most people with an Achilles rupture are offered blood-thinning medication, at least until they are walking on the leg. Aspirin does not appear to prevent clots after this injury. Seek urgent medical help if you develop calf pain or swelling, chest pain or shortness of breath. Read more about blood clots.

If you have heel pain without a sudden injury, see my page on Achilles tendon problems at the heel.

Book a consultation in London

If you think you have ruptured your Achilles tendon, or want advice on treatment, I can see you promptly and assess the tendon with ultrasound in clinic. Request an appointment or message us on WhatsApp.