Big Toe Cheilectomy

Cheilectomy is an operation for early to moderate arthritis of the big toe joint (hallux rigidus). It removes the bone spurs on top of the joint that block the toe from bending upwards, relieving pain while keeping the joint. I perform cheilectomy in London, at Guy’s and St Thomas’ and privately at The Wellington Hospital and 30 Devonshire Street. In well-chosen patients, more than 9 in 10 are satisfied with the result.

What is big toe arthritis?

The main joint of the big toe, at the base of the toe, takes a lot of load when you walk and push off. In hallux rigidus, the cartilage in this joint gradually wears, and bone spurs form on top of it. This causes pain, a bony lump on top of the joint, and stiffness, especially when the toe bends upwards. You can read more about big toe arthritis on the British Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society website.

Who is cheilectomy suitable for?

Cheilectomy works best when:

  • The arthritis is at an early or moderate stage
  • The main problem is a painful bump on top of the joint
  • Pain comes mainly when the toe bends upwards, such as when pushing off or going up on tiptoe

If the toe is painful through its whole range of movement, the cartilage is usually more badly worn, and a big toe fusion may give a more reliable result. I will examine your foot and review your X-rays to advise which operation suits you.

Treatment without surgery

Many people manage well without an operation. Options include stiff-soled or rocker-sole shoes, insoles that limit bending at the joint, painkillers and anti-inflammatory medication, and injections into the joint. Surgery is worth considering if pain continues to limit your walking or activities despite these.

What happens during cheilectomy?

Cheilectomy is a day case, so you go home the same day. It is done under general anaesthetic, with a nerve block to numb the foot so you wake up comfortable. The operation takes around 30 minutes.

Through an incision on top of the big toe joint, I remove the bone spurs from the end of the long bone (the metatarsal) and from the base of the toe, along with up to about a third of the top of the joint where the cartilage has worn. I also remove inflamed joint lining and any loose fragments. The aim is to restore good upward movement of the toe.

I use an open technique, rather than keyhole surgery, because it lets me see and clear the joint fully. In one study comparing the two, complications were less common after open cheilectomy (about 3 in 100) than after the keyhole approach (about 11 in 100).

Recovery after cheilectomy

The first two weeks

The nerve block keeps the toe numb for several hours after surgery. You can walk on the foot straight away in a stiff-soled surgical sandal. Crutches can help at first, but most people don’t need them. Keep your foot raised and use ice as much as you can to control swelling. Keep the dressing clean, dry and in place until your first check.

Weeks 2 to 6

I will see you at around two weeks to remove the dressing and check the wound. You can then move into comfortable, wide-fitting shoes, such as trainers. You will start exercises to bend the toe up and down straight away, and physiotherapy can help. These exercises are essential to keep the movement gained at surgery. Pain is usually minimal by this stage.

The final movement in the toe is usually a little less than what was achieved during the operation, so keeping up the exercises makes a real difference.

From six weeks

Most people return to normal activities, including sport and exercise, from around six weeks, building up gradually. Some swelling of the forefoot is common and can take several months to settle completely.

When can I drive and go back to work?

Desk-based work is usually possible after one to two weeks. You can drive once you can wear a normal shoe, brake firmly and are no longer taking strong painkillers. If the surgery is on your left foot and you drive an automatic, this may be sooner. Check with your insurer before driving.

How successful is cheilectomy?

More than 9 in 10 well-chosen patients are satisfied, with a clear improvement in pain and function. Cheilectomy does not cure the underlying arthritis, though. It tidies up the joint, removing the spurs and improving movement, but the arthritis may continue to progress over time and the spurs can grow back.

About 1 in 3 people have some pain return, usually within the first two years, even if they don’t need more surgery. About 1 in 12 to 1 in 20 eventually need another operation, usually a fusion. This is more likely if the arthritis is already advanced at the time of cheilectomy.

Occasionally, the cartilage inside the joint turns out to be more worn than the X-rays suggested. In that case, a cheilectomy is unlikely to last, and a big toe fusion is the better operation. We will discuss this possibility before surgery, so you know in advance what I would recommend if it happens.

What are the risks of cheilectomy?

Complications are uncommon. These risks should be read alongside the general risks of foot and ankle surgery.

  • Wound problems or infection. About 3 in 100. Usually minor and treated with dressings or antibiotics. I give antibiotics at the time of surgery to reduce the risk.
  • Nerve injury. A small skin nerve runs over the inner side of the toe. If it is irritated or injured, it can cause numbness, tingling or a tender spot along the inside of the toe.
  • Ongoing pain or stiffness, and progression of the arthritis over time.
  • Blood clots. Rare after this operation. I assess your individual risk and take steps to reduce it. Read more about blood clots after surgery.
  • Rare complications include complex regional pain syndrome (a long-lasting pain condition with swelling and colour changes in the foot) and new bone forming in the wound.

Smoking increases the risk of wound problems, so it is important to stop around the time of surgery.

When to get help after surgery

Contact us or seek medical advice if you have:

  • A fever, spreading redness, leakage from the wound, or a wound that opens up
  • Calf pain or swelling, or shortness of breath
  • Severe pain, much worse than expected, or colour or temperature changes in the foot

Book a consultation in London

If big toe pain and stiffness are limiting your walking, I can assess whether cheilectomy, fusion or a non-surgical treatment is right for you. Request an appointment or message us on WhatsApp.